top of page
logo
Subscribe now

Why Athletes Choke Under Pressure

Writer: ThePerformancePrescription
ThePerformancePrescription
Oct 11
6 min read


Welcome Everyone! As you can read in my bio, I am a full-time student, so I'll post as much as I can, but it may fluctuate depending on my course load. That said, welcome to the first article! For most articles, I'll include both a short version that gives a general idea of the topic and a longer version that goes into more depth on the research behind it.


The Short Version:


We all know and have felt the choking feeling, but what is it, really? Choking is performing worse than your skill level would predict, especially when the moment feels high-stakes. Research points to two main causes. When the moment feels especially high-stakes, that pressure pulls your attention inward. This makes movements that normally happen unconsciously conscious, which breaks them down. Next, worrying about the stakes eats up the mental energy needed for the task at hand.

​

Good news though! Choking is predictable. Predictability also means it's trainable. A consistent pre-performance routine, reframing techniques, learning to focus outside your body, and practicing under realistic pressure are all research-backed ways to prepare for the typical choke moment.

​

Choking isn't a lack of mental toughness or a character flaw. It is a typical brain response, and you can build skills to combat it.

​

Want the full story? Keep reading.


Long Version:

​

I’m sure most people reading, athlete or not, know what it feels like to choke under pressure. You’ve practiced for countless hours, and then, at the final moment, you feel your entire body go numb, as if you're not even in control. Suddenly the chance is over, and you lose it to a mistake that would never have occurred at any other time. That's choking: performing worse than your skill level would predict, because the stakes feel high. It is not just a random fluke or an off shot; it follows a pattern researchers have studied for decades.

​

I remember my first official match in college: up match point in a third-set tiebreaker, I missed an easy overhead long, and no joke, I am now several years post-grad and still think about that point. The ultimate choke. If only I had this article beforehand!

​

Why does that even happen? Great question; the research points to two main explanations.

​

Explanation One: Thinking Too Much

​

When you are first learning a skill, you have to think through every step individually. But after tons of repetition, that skill will become an automatic part of your repertoire. It can operate entirely without attention, so your brain has space to focus on other tasks, like planning your next shot or reading your opponent's body language.

​

Pressure can undo all your hard work, even when skills are automatic. When the stakes rise, many athletes start paying close attention to movements that typically require no thought at all. Psychologists call this explicit monitoring. Sian Beilock and Thomas Carr found that experienced golfers putted worse under pressure, and their results suggested pressure pushed extra attention onto the step-by-step mechanics of the stroke (Beilock and Carr, 2001).

​

Richard Masters described a related idea called reinvestment. Under pressure, people “reinvest” conscious, rule-based knowledge into a skill that used to run on its own (Masters, 1992). His research also notes an interesting twist: people who learned a skill with fewer explicit rules to think about seemed to hold up better under stress. This may be because they have less time to overthink and fewer steps to overthink.

​

The result is like trying to walk up stairs while thinking about each muscle in your legs. This breaks down automatic skills into little pieces, making it slower, stiffer, and less accurate.

​

Explanation Two: Worry Blocks Focus

​

This part focuses on distraction. Anxiety brings about countless thoughts: the crowd, score, your coach, parent, what losing would be, etc. Those thoughts take up vital space in your working memory, a key workspace you use to make decisions and hold information in mind.

​

Attentional control theory offers one reason why. It promises that anxiety weakens the brain's goal-directed attention system and makes us more drawn to distractions and threats (Eysenck et al., 2007). The theory also suggests that anxious performers can often keep up their results for a while by working harder. Still, it costs more effort, making performance less efficient and more fragile.

​

This kind of choking seems to matter most for tasks that need active thinking, like reading the game, choosing shots, or making quick decisions.

​

So… what helps?

​

Choking follows predictable patterns; this means there are concrete ways to train against it.

​

  1. Focus on the target, not your body - Research led by Gabriele Wulf suggests that focusing on the effect of a movement usually works better than focusing on the body. The size of this benefit is still debated, but the direction is fairly consistent. In practice, think about the result of the action, such as where you want your shot to go, and not what your body is doing, such as extending your leg or moving your wrist.

  2. Build a pre-performance routine - The number of ball bounces before a serve, the same breath before a penalty shot. These routines give attention to a familiar, useful place to go, instead of drifting into worries or mechanics.

  3. Hold a steady “quiet eye” - The quiet eye is the final steady gaze on your target just before you move. In one study, elite golfers who received brief quiet-eye training kept a longer, steadier final gaze under pressure, holed 60% of putts in a pressure test compared with 36% for a control group, and took fewer putts per round in real competition afterward (Vine et al., 2011). This was a small study, but it ties into a broader pattern linking steady pre-movement gaze to performance.

  4. Reframe nerves as excitement - Probably my favorite one. Telling yourself to “calm down” often doesn't work, because those bodily feelings are hard to switch off. Research by Alison Wood Brooks found that people who reframed their pre-performance anxiety as excitement, simply by saying “I am excited,” performed better on stressful tasks than those who tried to calm down (Brooks, 2014). Nerves and excitement feel similar in the body, and renaming nerves as excitement can shift how you approach the moment. I even carry this with me today in school, reframing my pre-exam or pre-clinical nerves as excitement.  

  5. Practice under pressure - If you only feel pressure on game day, it will always feel foreign. A 2020 meta-analysis of 14 studies in sport and law enforcement found that pressure training, deliberately adding consequences, competition, or evaluation to practice, had a medium-sized positive effect on performance under pressure for both beginners and experienced performers (Low et al., 2020). Small stakes help, such as finishing each practice with a “must make” clause, or the loser cleans up post-practice.

  6. Use one cue word - Replace a running checklist in your head with a single, outcome-focused word. It gives your mind something to hold onto without breaking the skill apart.


When it's more than nerves

​

The one thing my dad would always tell me before matches is that “nerves are normal”; they can even be helpful to a certain extent. But if anxiety starts showing up outside of sport, such as panic symptoms, trouble sleeping, dreading practice, or feeling like your value/worth is dependent on results, it could be time to talk with a mental health professional. It can be hard to separate athletics from self-worth since you are always playing the sport, and many athletes wait too long to ask for help, feeling like struggling means weakness. It doesn't.

​

Bottom Line

​

The bottom line is that choking isn't a lack of toughness; it's what your brain does under pressure. It pulls attention inwards and fills you up with worry. But knowing that means you can work with it. Train where your attention goes, build routines you trust, get comfortable being under pressure in practice, and treat your nerves as energy, not a threat.

​

Educational content from a student. Not medical advice.

​

Sources

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page